[Resolved] Carlos Brito Vs Carlos Enrique Brito Benvavides
Started by Maherto over 9 years ago, 10 replies
-
Maherto edited over 9 years ago
Carlos Enrique Brito Benavides, but the first one is his artist name, so it should be activated again, as Carlos Enrique Brito Benevides is his complete name, not his artist name:
https://www.google.es/search?q=carlos+brito&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&aq=t&rls=org.mozilla:es-ES:official&client=firefox-a&channel=sb&gfe_rd=cr&ei=D1dFV5CoBMOs8wfsj4X4Ag#channel=sb&q=carlos+brito+sombras
https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosario_Sansores
With that new artist name, Carlos Enrique Brito Benevides, only credited on 3 releases from his 23 credits:
https://www.discogs.sie.com/artist/1600291-Carlos-Enrique-Brito-Benavides?noanv=1 -
Show this post
@ Maherto, your spotting incorrect profiles might be useful to the database, but you should learn to do the updates yourself instead of just letting comments:
1) many s (and maybe most of them) don't react to comment
2) thus creating or leaving two profiles of which only one is valid. -
Show this post
???
I added comments on releases to let other s know info is wrong and to invite tehem to discuss the problem here.
And do you suggest to correct the wrong info on my own and by myself without consulting others?
Please mark Carlos Brito to be able to use it. -
Show this post
If "Carlos Brito" is his artist name, it make sense to make it a valid PAN.
However, as some (but few) releases use his full name, I suggest to keep that valid too, with alias-links, and description of the use. -
Show this post
https://www.discogs.sie.com/release/1968025-La-Pasión/history#latest
Also is best to keep the most complete name.
Maherto, send a Request to staff if you not agree. I will gladly accept what Database manager say. (As I did in the past) -
Show this post
At this stage, I'd rather count on best consensus as possible from this thread.
Another point in favor of keeping full name as ANV is that it's improving the search capacity (Carlos Brito, as well as Carlos Brito Benavides) going to the same entry, what is lowering the risk of creating additional PANs. Alias could also be a solution.
Let's have more from others on this one. -
Show this post
UriahCego
Carlos Enrique Brito Benavides is the older entry on database.
https://www.discogs.sie.com/release/1968025-La-Pasión/history#latest
Also is best to keep the most complete name.
That has nothing to do - his artist name is just Carlos Brito, not his complete name.
Michael Phillip Jagger is not Mick Jagger's artist name...
The PAN must be his more used name, and that one is without any doubs Carlos Brito or C. Brito, not the actual PAN. -
Show this post
eilifhh
If "Carlos Brito" is his artist name, it make sense to make it a valid PAN.
However, as some (but few) releases use his full name, I suggest to keep that valid too, with alias-links, and description of the use.
That would be useless - same as having Mick Jagger and Michael Phillip Jagger. If a release uses a variation of https://www.discogs.sie.com/artist/1600291-Carlos-Enrique-Brito-Benavides?noanv=1
I've checked the 3 ones using Carlos Enrique Brito Benavides now, and:
- on Alberto Plaza - La Mitad De Mi Mundo, is wrong, he's credited as Carlos Brito Benavides.
- on Various - Los Grandes Del Pasillo is wrong, credited as Carlos Brito
- only credited with that name in 1 release: Luz* - La Pasión
So I think it's pretty clear. Please see forum discussion about similar complete name https://www.discogs.sie.com/forum/thread/708543 -
Show this post
Please someone could validate Carlos Enrique Brito Benavides to start correcting releases? -
Show this post
Carlos Brito now updated, but the wrong one should be invalidated.