-
Show this post
On this release Tina Turner.
In fact, it's of course written by Ben Tucker as "Coming Home Baby".
Si I fixed it on Le Steel-Band De La Trinidad* - Magie Caraïbe.
Was it in the right way?
Is this possible to fix it on all other releases?
Thanks. -
Show this post
The problem is it is credited on the release and labels to Tina Turner. -
Show this post
"Is this possible to fix it on all other releases?"
Each release will have to be edited separately.
One way of doing it is by use of [Miscredited] + an unlinked Written-By credit, plus another linked Written-By with [Uncredited].
Coming Home
Written By [Miscredited] T. Turner
Written-By [Uncredited] Ben Tucker
Make sure to provide some sort of proof that the track in question is indeed the Ben Tucker song/composition. -
Show this post
My favorite part is a number of them have T. Turner as an ANV of Ben Tucker which is the single most incorrect way to do any of this.
I would follow duchamp163's suggestion:
Written By [Miscredited] T. Turner
Written-By [Uncredited] Ben Tucker -
Show this post
cellularsmoke
My favorite part is a number of them have T. Turner as an ANV of Ben Tucker which is the single most incorrect way to do any of this.
I would follow duchamp163's suggestion:
Written By [Miscredited] T. Turner
Written-By [Uncredited] Ben Tucker
Thanks for your replies. I think you're right.
Just to compare music:
.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rKDd5wDluX4&t=1s
with some titles signed by Ben Tucker:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=frOkJBw2zr0&t=46s
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L9Af6CF4g58&t=54s
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vDiRsT7_1-U&t=37s
and a lot more.
I'll add when I search "Tina Turner Coming Home" I get
https://www.discogs.sie.com/search?limit=250&q=tina+turner+coming+home&type=all&page=1
I see nowhere this title signed by Tina Turner except this record. Curious!
And "Ben Tucker Coming Home"
https://www.discogs.sie.com/search?q=Ben+Tucker+Coming+Home&type=all
There are different records signed by him. -
Show this post
Duchamp163
A completely incorrect way that should not be used.. RSG §1.7.2 is crystal clear how this is handled.
One way of doing it is by use of [Miscredited] + an unlinked Written-By credit, plus another linked Written-By with [Uncredited]. -
Show this post
Duchamp163
Written By [Miscredited] T. Turner
Written-By [Uncredited] Ben Tucker
cheebacheebakid
A completely incorrect way that should not be used.. RSG §1.7.2 is crystal clear how this is handled.
So why would Duchamp163's suggestion be "completely incorrect"? Seems like an elegant solution, IMO, and one that is not inconsistent with RSG §1.7.2
Written By [Miscredited] T. Turner —> lists what is actually credited on the the release without actually crediting Tina Turner, since it's unlinked; therefore, it will not appear on her profile.
Written-By [Uncredited] Ben Tucker —> fulfills RSG §1.7.2 with the actual correction, which is actually uncredited, and it needs to be identified as such as required by RSG §10.7.1.
So, all that's needed are:
The source in the sub notes (and further explanation if necessary), which, seems to me, would be needed for the correction anyway;
And a succinct remark about the error in the release notes.
Should then be all good.
[edit: punctuation] -
Show this post
Duchamp163
Written By [Miscredited] T. Turner
Written-By [Uncredited] Ben Tucker
This works well and IMO is not contradictory to aforementioned rule -
Show this post
Yes, for me also, it works well. Totally logical. -
Show this post
Duchamp163
Coming Home
Written By [Miscredited] T. Turner
Written-By [Uncredited] Ben Tucker
This suggestion looks reasonable to me.
ed. -
Show this post
excellent pragmatic solution. well thought out. thanks to all for your input on this. my contributions are quite minimal. i am more of a hands-on person than a screen-based communicator but i like to follow all developments -
Show this post
Your opinion is à participation. Thanks. -
Show this post
Great job resolving this dastardly conundrum.